Oak island money pit carbon dating

Honestly, I am not convinced of any of the stories about what happened on the island. The only I know that has been verified is the former black slave who lived and farmed there. After 4 years of this show, who knows what the real truth is. Joy's story makes as much sense as anything else at this point. Craig, Add to that an island inhabited, with a high water table, seems like a lousy place to bury treasure.

The Oak Island Money Pit - what the heck is down there?

Forum Rules. Advertise Here! What is it? What Is It? The Best Of Page 2 of 3 First 1 2 3 Last Jump to page: Results 16 to 30 of Originally Posted by Eldo. It does seem to be they found some other tunnels back in the day too there were the five fingers of death from smiths cove, the single tunnel to the south cove, and they said there may have also been another tunnel leading to that area you are speaking about The search for "Truth" and "Justice" is my "Prime Directive.

Good thing you figured it out But he who knows forms, is able to grasp the unity of nature beneath the surface of materials which are very unlike. Thus is he able to identify and bring about things that have never been done before, things of the kind which neither the vicissitudes of nature, nor hard experimenting, nor pure accident could ever have actualized, nor even human thought dreamed of. And thus from the discovery of the forms flows true speculation and unrestricted operation.

New Gold. I have a couple questions for you Robot as you seem to think you have this all figured out. It would have taken a fairly long time to do all that digging by hand. You really think a giant construction project like this would not have been reported by the locals? The island is a stone's throw from the mainland. I can understand a discrepancy of maybe a hundred years if the fibre had been stockpiled, but not one this big. Why not just leave it there? It's not like they really needed it.

The revolution was won by a bunch of poor farmers! Originally Posted by New Gold. Last edited by Robot; Nov 26, at Therefore offsetting the date of the carbon dating by up to a century. These are some of the most advanced trees to be able to live surrounded by the salt water, and live in the sands, rooting with little water or soil. These nuts that fall seasonally would be everywhere when they first arrived and there were thousands of trees in the Bahamas, a hop skip and a jump away from Nova Scotia for the Spanish in the area in the 's as well.

They spoke of a side chamber to gain access of the Temple in Jerusalem, it is likely there was a side chamber that was used to fill the chest, but who knows. Originally Posted by Robot. The preliminary work? How long do you think it would take a "company of cornish miners" to hand-dig the money pit, let alone the flood tunnels? This was no week long affair. Coffer dams had to be built, box drains had to be built, this was a major undertaking!

Even moving some of those boulders around would have been a daunting task! Work may have been done during the day under the guise of scraping the hull of a ship. How long does it take to scrape the hull of a ship vs build a network of tunnels a hundred feet below the ground? This could have been placed by any group of sailors happening to pass by the area looking to moor for the night. It would have made a good and accepted moorage for sea boats, due to its proximity to the mainland and the large tide variance in Mahone Bay.

See above. Anyone could have placed the ring, it was a high traffic area for sailors. A flotilla of ships surely would have caught the eye of the locals? It would have been near enough to clearly see. Frog island is still visible from the mainland. Camp fires burning on Frog island would be quite visible from the mainland. Any activity on either Frog or Oak islands for the amount of time this construction would have taken would have been noticed and surely remarked upon.

If they wanted to work in secret, which they obviously would have, they could have picked a better island! Maybe one not so close to the mainland? During the 18th Century and without electricity, locals tended not to go out or stray far from their lodgings at night. Lights seen at night were usually attributed to some sort of encampment or worse, part of evil folk lore.

So you admit that lights seen at night would have been noticed by the locals. Nowadays no one would even bat an eyelid. Back then a camp fire on an uninhabited island would have stuck out like a sore thumb. How exactly did they move those big granite boulders around? At night? Without making a hell of a ruckus? This is a giant Robot "assumption.

After months of camping and working on the islands, the presence of these workers would surely have been known to the locals. So why would the discoverers be surprised by a few lights in the darkness? Why didn't they find the true location of the vault buried just twenty feet below ground? Surely the dirt would have been fresh if the brits had just dug up their treasure? Surely it would take more than one night to dig up the vault and remove boatloads of treasure right?

Why didn't the boys see anything during the day? What home could be more protected than this? A vault system deep below ground with flood tunnels connected to the ocean? On an uninhabited island? Ain't no flood tunnels in Washington. Or New Ross for that matter. All the wood samples carbon dated support my theory's 18th Century time period. Wood, especially hardwood, is notoriously hard to carbon date. This is known as the old wood effect. The heartwood of hardwood species is usually centuries old by the time the tree is felled.

If the wood is taken from different parts of the tree it will date differently. Not to mention the fact that eighteenth century wood was likely used in the nineteenth century exploration of the money pit. All the items found on the island support my theory's 18th Century time period. So spanish maravedis from support your theory's timeline? How about the boatswain whistle carved out of ivory?

The british navy did not use whistles like this. Cornish pick axe could easily have been used during one of the nineteenth century excavations. A pick axe is a pick axe. Likely earlier than that. It was not until I reread R. This was the probability that these Coconut Fibers did indeed come from the West Indies and not from the Caribbean and Central America. Where I was wrong was in presuming that in the 18th century there was an industry in the Caribbean and Central America producing Coconut Fibers and these Fibers came from this part of the World.

It makes more sense that the Coconut Fiber Industry was only in Malaysia. Spanish ships from the West Indies would cart supplies and trade to Havana and off load and store this packing material prior to taking the gold shipments back to Spain. The Keppels would have had boat loads of this material stored at Havana, readily available for their plans at Oak Island.

Clearly it wasn't much of an industry if they hadn't produced any new stuff in four hundred years. Your reasoning still does not explain this huge age discrepancy. Also, many of the items you describe could have washed up on shore or been brought to the island by british settlers. You are making leaps again. Just because a pair of spanish scissors are found does not mean that it was spaniards on the island does it?

This allows for the Scientist who documented the history of the Coconut Seed to be correct in that although the Coconut Tree arrived in the Caribbean during the 16th Century there was not a flourishing Coconut Fiber Industry outside of Malaysia prior to the 's ad. This allows him to be correct? Interesting wording. It still does not explain why the fibre is carbon dated to five hundred years before your timeline.

This theory would still disqualify Vikings, Knights Templar and Druids as possible builders, as they did not have access to this quantity of fibers in their time period from the West Indies. Arab writers from the 11th century describe the extensive use of coir on their ships. Fact is you have no idea what they really had access to.

Radiocarbon (C) dating is one of the most reliable of all the radiometric dating methods. It has been utilized to scientifically test organic Oak. OakIsland). submitted Why couldn't the piece dated up to be original? The money pit was discovered so it predates the discovery.

The Oak Island mystery refers to stories of buried treasure and unexplained objects found on or near Oak Island in Nova Scotia. Since the 19th century, a number of attempts have been made to locate treasure and artifacts. Theories about artifacts present on the island range from pirate treasure, to Shakespearean manuscripts, to possibly the Holy Grail or the Ark of the Covenant, with the Grail and the Ark having been buried there by the Knights Templar.

Katie Lambert: And we're going to start off this episode with a little personal anecdote.

Oak Island, in Nova Scotia, is famous for its Money Pit, a mystery that has endured two centuries, claimed six lives and swallowed up millions in life savings. The Pit was discovered in by a local boy named Daniel McGinnis who, spotting an unusual clearing in the earth under one of the island's oak trees, was prompted to start digging. The discovery of layered planks, mysterious stone slabs, and mats made of coconut fibers descending deep into the ground turned his casual afternoon dig into an all-out excavation.

Oak Island mystery

Members Portal. This mysterious treasure pit on a Nova Scotia island has a fascinating natural explanation. Filed under Ancient Mysteries , Urban Legends. Skeptoid Podcast November 25, Podcast transcript Subscribe. It began as every boy's dream adventure, like a chapter from Tom Sawyer. On the eastern end of the wooded island he found something out of place:

For Sale: Island with Mysterious Money Pit

Forum Rules. Advertise Here! What is it? What Is It? The Best Of Page 2 of 3 First 1 2 3 Last Jump to page: Results 16 to 30 of Originally Posted by Eldo. It does seem to be they found some other tunnels back in the day too there were the five fingers of death from smiths cove, the single tunnel to the south cove, and they said there may have also been another tunnel leading to that area you are speaking about The search for "Truth" and "Justice" is my "Prime Directive.

Sign Up for our Newsletters. Jul 12, the dating.

Submission Guidelines. Thinking of famous historic treasure hunting, the first name that pops up in almost any extended conversation about the subject is Oak Island.

Oak Island carbon dating reports

During this process, the slurry from the chamber at the bottom of X is pumped up to the surface and deposited in a sediment tank. After running for some time, the airlift abruptly stops working. The machine operators suspect that some debris might be lodged in the upcoming hose and make some adjustments accordingly. In no time, the airlift is running smoothly again. After running the airlift for some time, the team decides that if there was anything of interest inside the chamber at the bottom of X, it should now be in the sediment tank on the surface. While shoveling, the treasure hunters discover several pieces of material they are unable to immediately identify, along with a small bone. These items are bagged and set aside for future analysis. Once all the X sediment has been transferred to the loader bucket, it is revealed that Jack Begley will be in charge of sifting through the debris. The next scene shows Begley and his stepfather Craig Tester sifting through the last of the X debris, which they have spread out on a diamond mesh trough. Immediately, the pair discover a hand-sized chunk of milled wood bearing the marks of an old-fashioned hand saw lying among the sludge.

oak island cross

Oak Island Treasure is pleased to announce the addition of some new documents to its growing archive. The first is a new section on coconut fibre. Large quantities of coconut fibre have been found beneath the beach at Smith's Cove. Records suggest that this is over a foot deep in some places. This has intrigued followers of the Oak Island mystery for years, given that coconuts are not found in that part of the world, pointing towards the creators of the Pit originating from more tropical lands. The selection of documents spanning the past eighty years detail the various investigations which have been conducted into this strange material.

Research - Folder View

How in the world do we get this stupid and irrelevant to history show from the history channel? I am not a fan of mainstream history and propaganda delivered through such channels as the history channel but I am not ready to lose my life to this unfounded l, unproven, unresearched waste of my time such as ancient aliens. Nothing makes me want to read my own selection of books and referenced books from friends and associates than watch tv when I see this moronic placate to the masses in the form of this show. Bummer all around. If ya don't like the show, don't watch it. If one is intelligent and knows there is more than one way to skin a cat, and the show is interesting, then watch it.

The Oak Island Money Pit

They get down to 90 feet put are flooded out. They drill through 2 casks filled with "loose metal". Also recovered 3 gold chains links. A man was scalded to death by an exploding boiler. Cave-in pit investigated. Back to Contents. The Story.

Research - Folder View

Is pleased to announce the addition of some new documents to its growing. The first is a new section on. Large quantities of coconut fibre have been found beneath the beach at Smith's Cove. Then the show attacks radiocarbon dating because a test done by Brock University on a piece of wood from Oak Island and trumpeted on creationist websites returned the anomalous result of dating an object to 3, years in the future. This leads the show to attack carbon dating altogether, but another. Carbon dating of wood artifacts found on the island has the deposit being.

The Curse of Oak Island- Season 4, Episode 11: Presidential Secrets


Oak Island ~ Has Treasure Secretly Been Found?
Related publications